Creative sentence
A full mock funeral for the loser's season: casket (a shoebox with the roster printed inside), dress code, and a eulogy delivered by the loser mourning each player they mismanaged. League members offer condolences. Somber organ music is required by statute.
Budget note: this one costs nothing but dignity, which makes it a strong pick for leagues that would rather spend the pot on the champion than on the loser's downfall.
Seen in the wild: fantasypunishments.com
More creative punishments in the same weight class.
The loser enters an open adult spelling bee or bar trivia night completely solo, wearing a shirt printed with their fantasy team name and final rec...
The loser and volunteering leaguemates recreate a series of classic awkward family photos, matching sweaters, hand-on-shoulder poses, uncomfortable...
The loser completes a full defensive driving or driver's-ed course, in person, on a weekend, with no ticket to dismiss and no insurance discount to...
The loser buys gas station sushi and films a full fine-dining review: plating notes, mouthfeel, wine pairing suggestions. The review must be posted...